Book review of The Child of the Moat: A Story for Girls. 1557 A.D.

by I. B. Stoughton Holborn (Author)

Updated at: 10/02/2025

Step back in time to 1557 A.D. with I. B. Stoughton Holborn's "The Child of the Moat: A Story for Girls." This captivating classic follows a young girl confined by a literal and metaphorical moat, separating her from the wider world and its possibilities. The story explores themes of courage, resilience, and the yearning for freedom in a restrictive society. Through vivid descriptions and historical detail, Holborn paints a picture of a girl struggling against societal expectations, seeking knowledge and charting her own path. This timeless tale of self-discovery resonates with young readers today, offering a powerful message about loyalty, companionship, and the importance of following one's heart.

The Child of the Moat: A Story for Girls. 1557 A.D. (Classic Books)

4.7 / 4 ratings

Review The Child of the Moat

Oh, I absolutely adored "The Child of the Moat"! It's one of those books that completely swept me away. Knowing its fascinating origin story – a professor inspired by a young girl's complaint about dull girls' books on the Lusitania – only added to my enjoyment. The fact that it's a century old yet feels so fresh and engaging is a testament to Holborn's skill. It's genuinely exciting, a real page-turner, and I found myself completely invested in the protagonist's journey from the very first chapter.

The setting itself is captivating. This little village, encircled by a mysterious moat, immediately creates an atmosphere of intrigue. It’s not just a physical barrier, but a symbol of the constraints placed on the young girl, mirroring the societal limitations of women in 16th-century England. Holborn masterfully uses the moat as a backdrop for adventure, adding a layer of suspense and mystery that kept me guessing. I loved the way she described the village, making it feel incredibly real and alive; I could almost smell the air and hear the sounds of the period.

The story itself is wonderfully paced. There's a thrilling blend of action and quiet reflection. We get exciting sword fights and nail-biting chases – definitely enough to satisfy any young adventurer – but it's balanced beautifully with quieter moments that allow us to connect with the protagonist's inner thoughts and feelings. Her yearning for freedom, her struggle against societal expectations, her unwavering loyalty to her friends – these are all things that resonate deeply, regardless of age or gender. The dialogue is sharp and witty, adding to the overall charm of the story.

One of the things I appreciated most was the book's refusal to shy away from the historical context. The backdrop of the English Counter-Reformation adds another layer of complexity, subtly weaving historical events into the narrative without ever feeling preachy or overwhelming. It’s a great way to introduce young readers to a significant period of history in an engaging and accessible manner. The secret passages and hidden dangers added an element of classic adventure storytelling that I found completely delightful.

Honestly, I can see why someone suggested it would make an excellent Disney movie. It has all the elements: a strong female lead, a captivating setting, plenty of action, and a heartwarming story about self-discovery. "The Child of the Moat" isn't just a book for girls; it's a fantastic adventure story that anyone aged eleven and upwards can enjoy. It's a testament to the enduring power of a well-crafted narrative and a reminder that great stories, like great friendships, transcend time. I highly recommend it!